Saturday, January 10, 2009

When Does What We Look For In A Partner Change?


Alice Gorman wrote an article for O Magazine some time back outlining how, in a moment of despair over a bad love life, she compiled a list of 100 things she wanted in a man. Her list was very specific. She stuck the list in the back of her closet and forgot about it. Five years later she met the man who would become the real love of her life. During an argument with him she produced the list. He matched up in every way except for two. She said that making the list was like giving up what she wanted to the Universe and this man was what the Universe sent her. Sort of like a “vision board” for a mate. Oprah also investigated this topic on her television show. There were several people interviewed on the show who had done this very thing successfully.

It got me to wondering, if I were to make such a list, what would be on it? I think my list would include such things as being open and honest, communicative, demonstrative and trustworthy. Self-supporting, shares some common interests with me and a sense of humor would also appear on my list. It occurred to me that no physical attributes, other than possibly being relatively physically fit and taller than me, came to mind. Even when I thought about it, I still couldn’t come up with any other physical attributes about which I cared.

Little girls tend to play imagination games including planning their weddings and what they want their boyfriend to be like. Ask any 10-year old girl how many bridesmaids she wants and I’ll bet she’ll be able to tell you without a moment’s hesitation. She probably also knows what her colors will be, all about her flowers and what songs will be sung at the reception. If you ask her about her boyfriend she will have that all figured out as well. She’ll most likely be able to describe him in detail. She probably will also tell you how many kids they’re going to have and about their pets. I remember my imaginary boyfriend was 6’2”, had blonde hair and blue eyes and was slim. I’m sure I spent a lot of time conjuring him up and dreaming about him. I had no thoughts at all about what sort of person he would be or what sort of values he would have. I suspect we spent a lot of time mooning around holding hands and gazing into each other’s eyes. Serious stuff! (Note – I’ve never, in all my "real" life, had a blonde boyfriend!)

Somewhere along in there, thankfully, we grow up and our wants and wishes change. Clearly that’s a good thing since I suspect all that eye gazing would get pretty tedious after awhile. When exactly does that happen? Does the change occur as a result of years or experiences? Obviously there is some of each but I wonder which has the stronger influence. I suspect it is experience. When we realize that our knight in shining armor might have a spot of tarnish on him and we’re okay with that, the change begins.

I guess I’ll make that list and throw it in the bottom of a drawer. I may or may not be posting on the results at some point in the future but, what the heck, it can’t hurt!

9 comments:

WomenBloom said...

Caught your post on Twitter.

Oh my, I could go on and on about this topic for days. I too have my list, maybe 50 qualities. I think it's telling that physical attributes did not show up on your list. In general, I think the externals become less important than the internals as we get older/more experience under our belt...if we're paying attention that is.

A man just popped into my life who is not on the surface what I expected, but the way he is in relationship is so much what I want, in spades, that sometimes I have to pinch myself.

My question is: at what point does the unexpected (not on The List) give you so much better than you could have imagined for yourself??

Mary said...

@WomenBloom - Congratulations! How does he measure up to the 50 things on your list?

I suspect that the more superficial the items one puts on their list, the less chance those items are what we really care about. In that case, I suspect the chances of finding someone and being surprised by how little resemblance they bear to the list we made, is great.

Good luck!

Fabulously Broke said...

I didn't make a list of what I wanted, but I sure as hell knew what I DID NOT want..

Process of elimination is what did it for me to find BF.

We do fight, BF and I .. but only because he's just as stubborn as me.. HAH!

But the main thing with a list is not to get hung up on the details. I just put down about 10 NON-NEGOTIABLES like:

1. No smokers

2. No druggies

3. No one obese

4. Cannot be shorter than me with 3" heels on

5. Must be open to at least TRY new things (cuisine for example)

6. Must want kids (more than 1)

7. Has to be good with his own finances

8. Has to have a job (yea.. not kidding on this one)

9. Must know how to pull his weight (in cooking, cleaning, laundry)

10. Has to be intelligent (smart enough to be stubborn with me)

And BF hits them all. ;)

Fabulously Broke in the City
Just a girl trying to find a balance between being a Shopaholic and a Saver...

Mary said...

Good for you FB! Self-supporting is definitely on my list! Great list - I'm right there with you except for the kids. Congratulations on holding out for what you wanted and getting it!

GutsyWriter said...

I met my husband through an ad in a magazine, but that was 22 year ago, when Internet dating didn't exist. I think being intelligent was one of my key requests, as I need someone who is mentally stimulating, about all topics. Also, physically, I wanted tall, as I'm 5'9". So the ads were easy to weed through, because anyone who claimed 6' tall, was generally 5'9". So I went for 6'2"-6'4" and that eliminated so many men right there. Very few claimed they were college graduates, or Masters degrees or above. I know Internet dating has all that information, but not when I was dating. If I were single today, I'd meet guys through my hobbies: working out in the weight room, writing classes at University extension programs, travel seminars.

Anonymous said...

I did the list and didn't think I was asking for anything I don't have to offer in return: advanced degree, physically active, has a passport, likes to travel, doesn't live at home, has a job, etc.

I'm so disappointed by how many men on internet dating sites lie about themselves, especially about dating exclusively when the time comes.

Any advice? I volunteer a lot and have tried to 'remain open to possibilities' by putting myself in situations to meet new people, but I'm ready to give up.

WomenBloom said...

Anonymous,

Don't give up. I too was absolutely discouraged and ready to give up the search. Then TSTT (Tall Slow Talkin' Texan) popped into my life. He matches many of the things on my list but not all: he isn't a technology person, he is not a cutting edge kind of guy embracing everything new, quite the contrary. But he doesn't keep me from being those things and he's great in how he is in relationship with me. I think that is ultimately the important thing.

I think just living your life and being active in your interests is a fine way to go about it. Just hang in there, it will happen when you least expect it.

Mary said...

@Anon -

I'm right with WomenBloom, don't give up. Stay open and enjoy yourself. It's great that you are involved in different activities but be sure you're not going to each one thinking "this might be it, I might meet my one and only today". That really sets you up for failure. Do things you enjoy doing. Enjoy the people around you simply becuase you do, not because they are possible date material. Keep the faith!

Funny about Money said...

Gosh. I'd just like a man who doesn't little-woman me and doesn't try to order me around. How hard is that?

Very, apparently. So far the only men I've met who fill the bill are either already married or gay.